It's that time of year again. Thanksgiving is just around the corner, and we're reminded to count our blessings and remember how fortunate we are. It’s customary to recognize and express appreciation for what we have and remember that there are others who have far less than we do.
And there's certainly nothing wrong with that. Gratitude can be a wonderful thing, and acknowledging the good in our lives is something worth cultivating.
But what happens when life isn't going particularly well? When we're dealing with illness, loss, financial worries, or any number of challenges that leave us feeling worn thin? What happens when gratitude feels like just one more thing we're supposed to do, and we can't quite muster it?
I sometimes wonder if, in our eagerness to encourage gratitude, we've turned it into an expectation rather than an experience. And in doing so, we might be making it harder for ourselves to feel the very thing we're trying to cultivate.
When Gratitude Becomes an Expectation
From childhood on, we’re taught to be grateful and say thank you when someone gives us something or does something kind. This lesson often comes with the best intentions in mind. But there’s a very real difference between encouraging appreciation and suggesting that someone is failing morally or emotionally if they can’t summon gratitude.
We commonly hear familiar responses to this struggle: Other people have it worse. At least you still have... You should be thankful for what you have. Statements like these might be meant well, but they can also be dismissive and leave someone feeling guilty — or even ashamed — about an already difficult experience. I don’t believe I’ve ever suddenly felt more gratitude after hearing things like this.
What might happen if, when gratitude is hard to conjure up, we just let it be as it is? What if we allowed ourselves and others to simply acknowledge that difficulty, without insisting that we feel differently or judging ourselves for how we feel?
There’s something I think a lot of people miss about gratitude: It shouldn’t require us to invalidate our feelings or our experiences.
The truth is, we can be grateful for the people who stand beside us and still grieve what we've lost. We can appreciate the good things in our lives while wishing our circumstances were different. One doesn't cancel out the other, and I don't believe we should feel compelled to choose between them.
The Difference Between Choosing and Forcing
We already know we have some influence over where we place our energy and our attention. We know we can decide to look for something good, however small, even in the midst of real challenge.
But here’s the thing: Recognizing the good isn’t necessarily the same as feeling grateful for it, and that’s something I think more people need to hear.
I’ve discovered something in my own ebb-and-flow relationship with gratitude, and I bet I’m not the only one. I’ve found that trying to force gratitude can all too easily become another way of judging ourselves, especially when we’re already struggling.
And therein lies the paradox: The harder we insist on feeling grateful, the further away gratitude can seem.
We can choose to look for something good, but we can't insist that gratitude follow.
And perhaps there's another option somewhere in the middle. We can acknowledge what we're going through, without judgment, while leaving the door open for gratitude to arrive in its own time. We don't have to force ourselves to feel something we're simply not feeling.
Looking Beyond What's Happening Right Now
I know what it’s like to feel a temporary absence of gratitude, and I suspect you do, too. It’s perfectly understandable when our immediate circumstances weigh more heavily than we can bear. Yet gratitude doesn't have to begin with what's happening in our own lives. Sometimes, it helps to look beyond them, toward something larger than whatever we're facing.
We might notice a beautiful autumn sky, an unexpected act of kindness between strangers, some encouraging news from a friend, or something funny that makes us laugh. Sometimes these little moments of delight and surprise can bring a brief but meaningful sense of joy, even when the rest of life feels difficult.
The key here is that we’re not using those things to deny our own suffering. We’re simply acknowledging that the difficulties we’re facing aren’t the only things that exist. And even if a sense of gratitude doesn’t follow, noticing something good is worthwhile in and of itself.
And if we don't feel like looking for those moments right now, that's okay, too.
Trusting That Gratitude Can Return
There are times when we’re so consumed by what we’re going through that there’s little room for anything else. That doesn’t mean we’ve lost our capacity for gratitude, and it certainly doesn’t make us an ungrateful person. Remembering times when gratitude came naturally might help reassure us that those feelings are still possible, even if they seem far away right now.
The sincerest form of gratitude isn’t something we manufacture. It’s something we experience, often with our full awareness. It might return in an unexpected way, in the unlikeliest of moments. An ordinary moment might suddenly become precious, and a small gesture might remind us of the goodness in life.
Even when gratitude feels elusive, we can leave ourselves open to the possibility that it will return naturally, without effort, and that thought alone can be comforting when we're struggling. There's no need to rush things or set a deadline for those feelings to return.
An Invitation, Not an Assignment
Thanksgiving will be here before we know it, and you may be preparing a list of everything you’re grateful for. For some of you, that list will be easy, and for others, it might feel challenging. Either way, here’s something I’d like to leave you with as the day approaches:
You are allowed to experience the holiday just as you are.
It’s enough to hold the possibility of gratitude without demanding it of yourself. You can appreciate what’s good, acknowledge what’s difficult, and leave room for both to exist side by side. It doesn’t make you a bad person if gratitude feels more elusive than you’d like — it makes you human.
Here’s wishing you a safe and peaceful Thanksgiving, whether you’re feeling grateful or not.
With you on the journey,
Julie 🍂